Un abonnement mensuel de 10$, 20$ ou 35$ peut faire une grande différence.

Vous apercevez quelque chose que nous devrions vérifier ? Écrivez-nous.

Analysis: The noose and its implications for Canada’s Black communities

During the second Senate reading of propo­sed Bill C‑9 titled An Act to amend the Crimi­nal Code, on April 14, 2026, Independent Senator Paulette Senior sugges­ted inclu­ding the noose as a hate symbol. That sparked some comments on social media surroun­ding the symbol that can obscure Canada’s sometimes overloo­ked history. While some argue the noose is prima­rily linked to capital punish­ment, some histo­rians say its associa­tion with racial intimi­da­tion extends into Canada’s past and present.

VérifRa­dar inter­vie­wed Natasha Henry-Dixon, profes­sor of African Canadian history at York Univer­sity, to provide more histo­ri­cal and contem­po­rary context on it, as well as a better unders­tan­ding of the mecha­nisms pertai­ning to the symbol in relation to Black commu­ni­ties in Canada. The second Senate reading was comple­ted on April 30, and the bill is being consi­de­red by the Standing Senate Commit­tee on Human Rights, per the Parlia­ment of Canada website.

Screen capture: April 14, 2026 senate procee­dings, CPAC.

The noose as a symbol speci­fi­cally used to target Black people goes beyond public hangings, accor­ding to histo­rian Natasha Henry-Dixon. She points out that the symbol is still being used today, carrying racial intimi­da­tion and violence present in Canada’s history and overlap­ped by the United States’.

The noose is a symbol that some argue carries meanings other than purely being a hate symbol aimed at Black people and people of colour. Public hanging is a term that typically refers to the practice of capital punish­ment by the state, though it can be carried out by non-state actors.

“There’s a lot of racial intimi­da­tion throu­ghout Canadian history. Lynchings infor­med the decision by Black people in the U.S. to make their way north to Canada.” Natasha Henry-Dixon explains, such as a wave from Oklahoma in the early 20th century. “Public lynchings are carried out by mobs and are different than hanging by corpo­ral punish­ment, it is the extreme form.”

Black people make up more than two-thirds of lynching victims in the U.S. with close to 5,000 recor­ded cases, accor­ding to the Natio­nal Associa­tion for the Advan­ce­ment of Colored People’s own records in the U.S.

Lynchings were rare and not a common practice in Canada.

A Library of Parlia­ment document states that the last execu­tion in Canada was in 1962, and estimates that there were 710 recor­ded execu­tions by hanging between 1867 and 1962, without speci­fying demogra­phic distri­bu­tion. The records can be incom­plete and incon­sistent, accor­ding to resear­chers. There were public execu­tions before 1867, too.

Evidence of racial intimi­da­tion in Canada

“Broadly speaking there has not been documen­ta­tion by govern­ments, recor­ded public hangings of Black people in Canada. That being said, it was often used and threa­te­ned in a manner to keep Black people in place and in control.” Natasha Henry-Dixon says. “There were a few instances of crowds of white men who endea­vo­red to physi­cally harm and on the road of poten­tially lynching Black men in Canada.” the profes­sor conti­nues.

A person does not need to witness public hanging or lynching first-hand to unders­tand the noose’s possible anti-Black dimen­sion, it was histo­ri­cally publi­ci­zed by Canadian journa­lists, Profes­sor Henry-Dixon tells VérifRa­dar. “The reasons for which Black men were lynched in the U.S. circu­la­ted very promi­nently in Canadian newspa­pers as a way to fearmon­ger.” She deems that it was meant “to create this idea that the increa­sing number of Black people in the U.S. put the safety of white women in the U.S. at risk, and to maintain white racial purity.”

“There are several offshoots around this practice of lynching. There was an instance in Richmond Hill, Ontario, in 1862 where a Black man, who was a barber, was in a relation­ship with a white woman to which some of the commu­nity members took offense, to their inter­ra­cial relation­ship, and physi­cally assaul­ted the gentle­man. They vanda­li­zed and destroyed his barber shop and they tarred and feathe­red him.” the histo­rian says, to give one example.

Tarring and feathe­ring is a form of public torture and humilia­tion.

“There were several instances of cross burnings by Canadian KKK to intimi­date and instill fear. In 1930, Oakville, Ontario, there was a man with mixed ances­try engaged to a white woman, and with the police knowing, the KKK lit a cross on fire.” Natasha Henry-Dixon adds, to further illus­trate the climate of anti-Black mob violence in Canada, that is connec­ted to public lynching as opposed to hanging as a right for crimi­nal offences, she says.

Moreo­ver, “Canada had its own Sundown towns, where Black people were not allowed after the sunset,” the profes­sor also highlights.

The work of politi­cal scien­tist and histo­rian Allan Bartley suggests the Ku Klux Klan (KKK) made its way in Canada from the U.S. and exerted signi­fi­cant influence across the country during the 20th century that was enabled by Canadians’ existing preju­dices accor­ding to Bartley, as covered by CBC.

Contem­po­rary consi­de­ra­tions

There are indivi­duals still alive today who have witnes­sed and carry inter­ge­ne­ra­tio­nal trauma related to racial intimi­da­tion and violence in the U.S. and Canada. “At the end of the second World War, there was a Black man who witnes­sed the hanging of a Black man in the US, fled and came to Ontario.” profes­sor Henry-Dixon notes.

Despite the last recor­ded lynching dating back to 1981, some obser­vers consi­der that lynchings never stopped in the U.S., per analyses by Jill Collen Jeffer­son, repor­ted by the Washing­ton Post.

There are suspi­cious instances of Black men being hanged in the United States in recent years, though it hasn’t happe­ned in Canada, Profes­sor Henry-Dixon says. “The noose conti­nues to be invol­ved to intimi­date Black people in different sites in Canada. In the early 2020s, at construc­tion sites in downtown Toronto, nooses were actually placed.”

Black people wanting to migrate from the U.S. to Canada in the hopes of finding relati­vely more safety is not only a thing of the past. After Trump was elected for his first term in 2015, there was a spike in Google searches from people looking to escape to Canada, inclu­ding high profile African Ameri­cans publi­cly vocal about wanting to move north, a Bloom­berg news article repor­ted. That was also the case follo­wing Trump’s reelec­tion in 2024.

Note: Histo­ri­cal inter­pre­ta­tions can vary. VérifRa­dar attemp­ted to contact more expert sources and didn’t receive a response, more than two weeks later. Readers are encou­ra­ged to consult other sources.