Un abonnement mensuel de 10$, 20$ ou 35$ peut faire une grande différence.

Vous apercevez quelque chose que nous devrions vérifier ? Écrivez-nous.

Fact Check: Misleading to say Indigenous communities supported the residential-school system in the 1940s

Is it accurate to say that, in Canada, Indige­nous parents suppor­ted Chris­tian residen­tial schools in the 1940s, as Max Genest claimed on social media? No, that’s mislea­ding and lacks context. While some parents did support residen­tial schools, accor­ding to an expert, this claim does not take into account the histo­ri­cal context from 1947 and the constraints faced by Indige­nous peoples at the time. It also omits that the context was not the same in all the residen­tial schools from Canada over the century they lasted. The expert adds that a few quotes from a document taken out of context cannot seriously be compa­red to the conclu­sions from the Truth and Recon­ci­lia­tion Commis­sion. VérifRa­dar obser­ved that the document from 1947 cited by Max Genest contains criti­cisms of residen­tial schools, omitted by Genest.

In a video named “When chiefs suppor­ted Residen­tial Schools” posted on Tiktok (archi­ved here) and Facebook on October 4th, Max Genest claims that:

“1946 govern­ment records documen­ted that abori­gi­nal parents suppor­ted chris­tian residen­tial schools”.

Here is a screen­shot from that video:

(Source: video by @realmaxgenest on tiktok.com)

Max Genest then goes on to cite excerpts from a document called “Special Joint commit­tee of the senate and the house of commons appoin­ted to conti­nue and complete the exami­na­tion and consi­de­ra­tion of the Indian act”, from 1947. The excerpts in question indicate a certain degree of appre­cia­tion on the part of the Indige­nous commu­nity regar­ding residen­tial schools, but that does not tell the whole story.

At the end of his video, Max Genest can be heard saying:  

“Today the abori­gi­nal grievance indus­try demands truth and recon­ci­lia­tion. Yet, it does not believe in that. It denies inves­ti­ga­tions into the truth as that would destroy the market it controls on the grief indus­try. A market that paints residen­tial schools as slaugh­ter houses, then lobbies the govern­ment to make questio­ning the lie illegal.”

However, the documen­ta­tion and the expert consul­ted do not support the claim at the center of this fact check.

Eight quotes out of more than 1600 pages

Seven out of the eight quotes by Genest can be found in this document, and another one in this document. The documents contain different volumes from the “Special joint commit­tee of the senate and the house of commons appoin­ted to conti­nue and complete the exami­na­tion and consi­de­ra­tion of the indian act”, from 1947. These documents total more than 1600 pages.

In his video, Max Genest quotes most of the state­ments word for word, but omits impor­tant parts, highligh­ting a certain degree of satis­fac­tion among certain Indige­nous leaders regar­ding residen­tial schools.

For example, a quote cited by Genest and attri­bu­ted in the documents to Chief of the Wahna­pi­tae Band reads as follows:

“We are a Band that is comple­tely Catho­lic and our religion means a good deal to us. We are glad to be Catho­lics like over half the Indians in Canada are, and we want to stay that way. That’s why we don’t want to have the sligh­test thing to do with any kind of cheap public school.”

However, Genest does not include any criti­cism or reser­va­tions regar­ding the system that are present in this document. For example, Max Genest quotes a passage from the Alberta Indian Associa­tion that states: 

“Where unsui­table home condi­tions exist, Indian children should be removed from their parents just as white children are, when they are found to be neglec­ted.”

He failed to mention that, a few paragraphs earlier, the document speci­fies: 

“Though this Organi­za­tion fully recognizes and appre­ciates the value and service of the residen­tial school, it submits that the educa­tio­nal needs of many reserves to-day can best be served by the establish­ment of day schools in proxi­mity to the children’s homes” 

And it adds that:

“No child can develop as he should, without the care and affec­tion of family life. The restric­tions, disci­pline, exclu­sive use of English, etc. in the Residen­tial Schools are now recogni­zed as having a harmful effect on immature minds and bodies.”

More vocal critics can also be found in the documents. For example, Head chief Clifford White says: 

“ We do not recom­mend young Indian children being sent to Residen­tial Schools and would suggest that Church Socie­ties opera­ting such schools be paid for expenses and impro­ve­ments so that they do not lose any money ; then convert the Residen­tial Schools into High Schools, Vocatio­nal Schools and some into Indian Colleges.”

Lack of context, expert says

Accor­ding to Sébas­tien Brodeur-Girard, a profes­sor at the School of Indige­nous Studies at the Univer­sité du Québec en Abitibi-Témis­ca­mingue, Max Genest inter­prets documents in ways that are either taken out of context or fail to take into account elements that are impor­tant. 

For example, the expert recalls that 1947 was preci­sely a time when, at the colonial level, the enfor­ce­ment of the Indian Act was at its stric­test.

“At that time, it was still illegal for commu­ni­ties to fund a lawyer to assert their rights if they were exclu­ded by the govern­ment. (…) So, of course, the leaders would advocate as best they could, using whate­ver language they could, to make their community’s needs heard.”
« C’est encore illégal à ce moment-là pour les commu­nau­tés de finan­cer un avocat pour faire valoir leurs droits en cas d’être mis à part du gouver­ne­ment. (…) Donc, évidem­ment, les chefs vont plaider du mieux qu’ils peuvent,  avec le langage qu’ils peuvent, pour faire entendre les besoins de leur commu­nauté. »
Trans­la­ted by VérifRa­dar

He adds that it is indeed documen­ted that some parents wanted their children to attend residen­tial schools in order to receive an educa­tion and have a future, but that they were not neces­sa­rily aware of the types of abuse their children might be exposed to. He points out that compul­sory educa­tion could also be enfor­ced at the time, and reminds that there are documen­ted cases in which the RCMP would pick up children to take them to school.

“Of course, the parents didn’t want to leave their children, but it was made clear that if they didn’t, they risked being arres­ted or something like that, so they would have to do it. So some were more proac­tive, others weren’t. Some fled, others hid their children, this is well documen­ted.”
« Évidem­ment que les parents n’avaient pas envie de quitter leurs enfants, mais si c’est indiqué que sinon, on risque d’être arrêtés ou quoi que ce soit, on va le faire. Donc certains étaient plus proac­tifs, d’autres non. Il y en a qui sont enfuis, il y en a qui ont caché leurs enfants, ça aussi c’est documenté. »
Trans­la­ted by VérifRa­dar

Truth and Reconciliation Commission

Between 2008 and 2015, Canada held the Truth and Recon­ci­lia­tion Commis­sion.

Accor­ding to documents from the Govern­ment of Canada from 2023:

“Between 1867 and 1998, over 150,000 First Nations, Inuit and Métis children were taken from their families and commu­ni­ties. They were forced to attend residen­tial schools, where many were subjec­ted to horri­fic abuse. The Truth and Recon­ci­lia­tion Commis­sion estima­ted that more than 4,100 children never came home from residen­tial schools.“

Sébas­tien Brodeur-Girard points out that residen­tial schools for Indige­nous peoples were insti­tu­tions that opera­ted for over a hundred years.

“Of course, there were places where they worked. But there were also places, which are well-documen­ted, where there was a great deal of physi­cal, psycho­lo­gi­cal, and sexual abuse.”
« Bien évidem­ment qu’il y a des endroits où ça a fonctionné. D’autres endroits, c’est documenté aussi, qu’il y a eu des abus physiques, psycho­lo­giques et sexuels en grande quantité. »
Trans­la­ted by VérifRa­dar

In this context, he reite­rates that it is diffi­cult to genera­lize about the subject based on just a few excerpts. He believes it is more rigorous to rely on the work of the Truth and Recon­ci­lia­tion Commis­sion.

“Perso­nally, I would have much more confi­dence in work done by a public inquiry commis­sion that inter­vie­wed dozens and dozens of people. (…) To take an example based on a few snippets here and there, and then use that to establish a truth that contra­dicts the work done by hundreds of people, and now the testi­mo­nies of thousands of people, well, that’s not very serious.”
« Person­nel­le­ment, je ferais nette­ment plus confiance à un travail qui a été fait, par exemple, par une commis­sion d’enquête publique qui a rencon­tré des dizaines et des dizaines de personnes. (…) Donc, d’aller prendre un exemple avec quelques extraits par-ci, par-là, pour après ça établir une vérité contraire au travail fait par des centaines de personnes et aux  témoi­gnages de mainte­nant des milliers de personnes, bien, ce n’est pas très sérieux. »
Trans­la­ted by VérifRa­dar